S’mores Sandwiches If you’re a fan of the classic s’mores but want to enjoy them without needing a campfire, I’ve got just the recipe for you: S’mores Sandwiches

 

Why These S’mores Sandwiches Are So Good

S’mores are the ultimate comfort dessert: toasted marshmallows + melted chocolate sandwiched between crackers. S’mores (also spelled s’more) are a traditional American/Canadian treat made outdoors over a fire. ويكيبيديا+2ويكيبيديا+2
Turning that concept into a sandwich — bread, buns, or even cookies instead of only crackers — gives you the same irresistible combination of sweet, warm, gooey, crunchy and melt‑in‑your‑mouth, but in a format that’s easier to bake, grill, or serve anytime. One recipe even calls them “S’mores Grilled Sandwiches” using bread, butter, sugar, marshmallow cream and chocolate spread. The Grill Dads

What makes them special:

• The marshmallow gives soft meltiness and sweet chew.

• The chocolate adds richness and smooth melt.

• The outer bread/crumb layer gives structure and crisp or chewy contrast.

• Because you assemble the sandwich and toast/grill/oven‑bake, you replicate the “toasting” of marshmallows indoors.

• The sandwich format means portability: you can hand‑off, wrap, serve to guests easily.

---

Ingredients & Yield

Yield: about 6‑8 sandwiches (depending on size)
Prep Time: ~15–20 minutes
Cook Time: ~10–15 minutes (or grill/oven time)
Total Time: ~30‑35 minutes (ready to serve)

Ingredients – Basic Version

• 12 slices of thick white or brioche bread (for 6 sandwiches) OR 6 thick slices of bread if one‑slice‑fold version. (In the “grilled sandwich” version: 8 thick slices white or French bread for 4 sandwiches in the recipe) The Grill Dads

• 4 tablespoons (½ stick) unsalted butter, softened (for outer buttering)

• 1 tablespoon granulated sugar (sprinkled on the buttered side for caramelisation) The Grill Dads

• 2 (4‑ounce) chocolate bars (around 8 ounces total) or equivalent chopped chocolate pieces

• 5 ounces marshmallow cream or marshmallow fluff AND/OR large marshmallows (depending on method) The Grill Dads

• Optional: ½ cup chocolate‑hazelnut spread (e.g., Nutella) for variation (as seen in that same recipe) The Grill Dads

Ingredients – Creative Variation Options

• Alternative breads: brioche rolls (split for sliders), Hawaiian sweet rolls, brioche buns. Example: “S’mores Sliders” use brioche mini buns. snackworks.ca

• Additional fillings/toppings: banana slices, peanut butter, caramel sauce, cinnamon, pretzels for salty crunch. Example: bananas + chocolate + marshmallow in buns. snackworks.ca

• Alternative cook method: air‑fryer, oven broiler, grill. Example: one article uses air fryer for s’mores. TechRadar

• Use of sugar crust: buttered outside + sugar sprinkle gives caramelised outer shell. (In grilled sandwich version)

• Alternate “cookie sandwich” form: Use cookie dough, marshmallow, chocolate day‑time treat. Tastemade+1

---

Equipment & Preparations

• Grill or grill pan (medium/low heat) or oven (preadjusted) or air fryer (if using that method)

• Baking sheet lined with parchment, if using oven

• Knife and cutting board

• Butter knife or spreader

• Measuring spoons & cups

• Optional: spatula for flipping sandwiches

• Timer to avoid burning marshmallows/chocolate

Tip: If using bread, choose thick slices so the filling doesn’t ooze out too fast. If using buns/sliders, splitting and buttering outside yields a crisp golden exterior.

---

Step‑by‑Step Instructions

I’ll give you Method A: Grilled/Stovetop Sandwich, Method B: Oven or Air‑fryer Sandwich, and Method C: Creative Slider/Bun Variation so you can pick based on equipment and occasion.

Method A – Grilled/Stovetop S’mores Sandwiches

1. Prepare bread slices: Take 8‑12 thick bread slices (depending on yield). Take 4 tablespoons butter and soften; spread butter on one side of each slice. Sprinkling sugar over the buttered side gives extra sweetness and caramelisation. In the Grill Dads recipe: 8 thick slices for 4 sandwiches. The Grill Dads

2. Flip slices over: On the non‑buttered side of each slice, spread marshmallow cream or marshmallow fluff (or make a marshmallow layer). On four of the slices, spread chocolate‑hazelnut spread (or place chopped chocolate pieces) on the other side. In the Grill Dads recipe: one half gets marshmallow cream/fluff, the other gets chocolate + chocolate hazelnut spread. The Grill Dads

3. Assemble the sandwiches: Place the marshmallow side slice atop the chocolate side slice (butter‑sugar sides on outermost surfaces).

4. Heat the grill/pan: Pre‑heat a griddle or cast‑iron skillet to low heat (important so marshmallow heats through without burning the bread). The Grill Dads recipe indicates low heat. The Grill Dads

5. Grill the sandwiches: Place the sandwiches butter‑side down in the pan. Grill each side for ~2‑3 minutes until golden brown and sugar caramelised, then flip and grill the other side until the bread is crisp golden, the marshmallow is warm/soft, and the chocolate filling is melted.

6. Serve immediately: These are best served when fresh and gooey. Garnish if you like (slice banana on top, drizzle extra spread).

Method B – Oven or Air‑Fryer S’mores Sandwiches

1. Pre‑heat oven or air‑fryer: For oven method, pre‑heat to ~375 °F (190 °C). For air fryer, about 350–400 °F (175–200 °C) depending on model. Example: article on air‑fryer s’mores uses 400 °F / 200 °C. TechRadar

2. Prepare bread or buns: As before, butter outer sides, sugar optional, spread filling on inner sides.

3. Assemble sandwiches: Combine marshmallow side + chocolate side.

4. Place on baking sheet or air‑fryer basket: Lined with parchment if oven. For air fryer, place in single layer.

5. Bake/air‑fry:

   • Oven: Bake ~8‑12 minutes until bread is golden, chocolate melting, marshmallow warm. Flip halfway if desired.

   • Air‑fryer: ~6‑8 minutes or until golden and gooey (monitor carefully to avoid burning). The air‑fryer article describes quick heating: 1‑2 minutes choco soften + 2‑3 minutes marshmallow. TechRadar

6. Optional broil/finish: If you like marshmallow lightly toasted on top, switch to broil for last 30–60 seconds.

7. Serve while warm.

Method C – Creative Slider/Bun Variation

1. Choose mini buns: e.g., brioche mini buns (split). Example: “S’mores Sliders” use 4 large buns. snackworks.ca

2. Pre‑heat oven to ~400 °F (200 °C).

3. Prepare filling: Place banana slices, chocolate squares, marshmallows inside bottom bun halves (as in that recipe). Hers: banana + chocolate bar + 2 marshmallows on each. snackworks.ca

4. Top with cinnamon or sugar (optional).

5. Bake buns: Place in baking dish and bake ~6–8 minutes until marshmallows lightly toasted and chocolate melting.

6. Top with bun tops and let stand 2 minutes before serving. snackworks.ca

7. Serve warm. This format gives handheld slider fun.

---

Why Each Step Matters & Tips for Best Results

• Butter & sugar on outer bread surfaces: gives a crisp, golden caramelised exterior, enhancing texture and flavour (in grilled method). Without it, bread can be soggy.

• Low heat grilling: When using a pan, low heat ensures marshmallow melts and chocolate softens before bread burns.

• Bread thickness: Thick slices or buns help contain the melted fillings; thin bread may collapse or soak through.

• Assembly order: Spreading marshmallow on one side, chocolate on the other ensures even distribution and prevents instant meltdown when heated.

• Timing: Serve immediately after heating. The gooey‑melt texture is the highlight. If cooled too much, the sandwich may stiffen and lose appeal.

• Choice of fillings: Classic: chocolate bar + marshmallow. But adding banana, Nutella, peanut butter, pretzels adds dimension and variation (sweet/salty, fruity).

• Monitoring heat: Especially in broil/air‑fryer, marshmallows can burn quickly—they go from golden to charred fast. The article warns to watch closely. TechRadar

• Serving suggestion: Cut sandwiches in half for easier sharing; serve with a glass of milk or cocoa for full treat.

• Pre‑preparation: You can assemble sandwiches ahead and butter them later, but the fill/melt effect is best fresh.

---

Variations & Customisations

Here are many ways to adapt and elevate your s’mores sandwiches:

• Nutella & peanut butter twist: Spread Nutella + marshmallow fluff; add banana slices for “banana‑PB s’mores slider” style (as in the brioche variation).

• Salty‑sweet crunch: Add pretzel twist or salted cracker inside the bun (same brioche slider recipe gives this tip). snackworks.ca

• Cookie sandwich version: Use chocolate chip cookies or graham‑crumb cookies as outer layers rather than bread; fill with marshmallow & chocolate, freeze for treat. Example: “S’mores Cookie Sandwiches” by Tastemade. Tastemade+1

• Ice‑cream s’mores sandwich: Fill with softened ice cream, marshmallow, chocolate, sandwich between graham crackers then freeze. Example: S’mores Ice Cream Sandwiches. Farm Flavor+1

• Vegan or allergy‑friendly version: Use dairy‑free chocolate, vegan marshmallows (gelatin‑free), gluten‑free bread or buns, or crustless slider bread.

• Savory crossover: Though less classic, you could do “savory s’mores” with cheese & grill/foam – one site offers “Melty Ploughman’s S’mores” with brie + pickle. Good Food

• Campfire style at home: Use bread/bun + chocolate + marshmallow, wrap in foil and place near fire or grill for outdoor flavour without skewers.

• Add texture topping: Sprinkle chopped nuts (pecan, walnut), toasted coconut, or layer caramel drizzle on top before serving.

• Mini versions: Use slider buns or cut bread slices smaller for kids or party hors d’œuvres.

• Dessert upgrade: After grilling, top with whipped cream, fresh strawberry slices, or drizzle salted caramel for upscale version.

---

Troubleshooting & FAQ

Problem	Likely Cause	Solution
Bread burns before filling melts	Heat too high, bread too thin	Use lower heat, thicker bread, monitor closely
Marshmallow not gooey	Insufficient heat or cold filling material	Ensure marshmallow cream/fluff warms sufficiently, use large marshmallows
Filling oozes out	Bread too soft or sandwiches too thick	Use slightly thicker bread/bun, press sandwich gently after heating
Bread soggy or chewing	Over‑filled or bread under‑toasted	Use butter & sugar outer layer, moderate fill, toast properly
Chocolate doesn’t melt	Heat too low or chocolate too thick/chunky	Use thinner chocolate or spread; heat longer at moderate temp
Sandwiched falls apart	Bread not holding shape, over‑stuffed	Use buns with structure or compress sandwich slightly before serving

Pro Tips:

• Pre‑warm the marshmallow cream slightly (20‑30 seconds in microwave) if cold, so sandwich heats uniformly.

• When using chocolate bars, chop roughly so they melt faster.

• After heating, tent sandwich with foil for 30 seconds to keep warm and melty until serving.

• If buttering outside slices, carbonisation can occur if buttered side hits high flame—monitor and flip as needed.

• Use parchment when baking in oven to avoid sticking and ease clean‑up.

• If making ahead, it’s best to assemble, keep separate, and butter/heat just before serving for maximum texture.

---

Serving & Storage

Serving Suggestions:

• Serve each sandwich warm, right after heating, for optimal gooeyness.

• Pair with a cold glass of milk, hot cocoa, or coffee for contrast.

• Add fresh fruit (strawberries, banana slices) alongside to cut richness.

• Offer dipping sauces: extra chocolate sauce, caramel sauce, peanut butter drizzle.

• For parties: cut sliders in halves or quarters for bite‑sized servings.

Storage:

• These are best eaten fresh. If you must hold them, keep warm area or wrap in foil and place in very low oven (~150 °F / 65 °C) for up to 10 minutes. After that the bread may become soggy.

• If leftovers exist (unlikely!), you can refrigerate for up to 1 day but expect texture change; reheat in oven at ~300 °F for 5‑7 minutes to restore a bit of crisp.

• For ice‑cream sandwich variation: freeze portions wrapped in plastic wrap for up to 2 weeks (distinct recipe). albertsonsmarket.com

---

Story & Background

The classic s’more sandwich — two graham crackers, a toasted marshmallow, and a piece of chocolate — has been around since the early 20th century in USA/Canada. ويكيبيديا+1
By transforming that into bread or bun sandwiches (versus crackers) or even slider buns, we merge the nostalgic campfire treat with modern sandwich portability and comfort‑food format. The “grilled sandwich” version with buttered bread and sugar gives it a gourmet twist of French‑toast-esque exterior + gooey interior. The Grill Dads

It’s fun, shareable, and perfect for gathering or kids’ treat. Also, because you can make them with minimal equipment, they’re highly adaptable.

---

Printable Recipe Card

S’mores Sandwiches
Yield: ~6‑8 sandwiches
Prep Time: 15–20 min
Cook Time: 10–15 min
Total Time: ~30–35 min

Ingredients – Basic:

• 12 slices thick white or brioche bread (for 6 sandwiches)

• 4 Tbsp unsalted butter, softened

• 1 Tbsp granulated sugar

• 2 (4‑oz) chocolate bars (or equivalent chopped chocolate)

• 5 oz marshmallow cream or marshmallow fluff (or large marshmallows if you prefer)

• Optional: ½ cup chocolate‑hazelnut spread (Nutella) or peanut butter for variation

Instructions – Grilled/Stovetop Method:

1. Spread butter on one side of each bread slice; sprinkle sugar over the buttered sides.

2. On the non‑buttered side of half the slices, spread marshmallow cream; on the other slices spread chocolate‑hazelnut spread or place chopped chocolate.

3. Assemble sandwiches: marshmallow‑side slice + chocolate‑side slice (butter‑sugar sides facing out).

4. Pre‑heat a griddle or skillet to low heat.

5. Place sandwiches butter‑side down; grill for ~2‑3 min until golden and sugar caramelised. Flip and grill the other side until bread is golden, marshmallow warm and chocolate melted.

6. Remove and serve immediately.

Instructions – Oven/Air‑Fryer Variation:

1. Pre‑heat oven to ~375 °F (190 °C) or air‑fryer to ~350–400 °F (175–200 °C).

2. Prepare sandwiches as above (butter/sugar optional).

3. Place sandwiches on lined baking sheet (or air‑fryer basket) in single layer.

4. Bake/air‑fry ~8–12 min (oven) or ~6–8 min (air‑fryer) until bread golden and filling melty; flip halfway if desired.

5. Optional broil last 30–60 seconds for marshmallow toasty top.

6. Serve warm immediately.

Slider/Bun Variation:

1. Pre‑heat oven to ~400 °F (200 °C).

2. Use 4 brioche buns (split). On bottom halves place banana slices (optional), chocolate square(s), marshmallows. Sprinkle cinnamon if using. snackworks.ca

3. Bake ~6–8 minutes until marshmallows lightly toasted.

4. Top with bun tops and let stand 2 min. Serve.

Storage:
Best eaten fresh. If reheating, use low oven for a few minutes. For ice‑cream sandwich version, freeze as a separate recipe.

---

Final Thoughts

S’mores sandwiches combine the beloved flavors of toasted marshmallow and melted chocolate with the comforting sandwich format. Whether you’re using thick bread grilled on the stove, ovens for easy stack, sliders for fun gatherings, or even ice‑cream sandwich adaptations, the core delight remains: warm, gooey, sweet, and utterly satisfying.

Feel free to customise with banana, peanut butter, salty pretzels, or vegan versions. The key is assembly, heat, and serving quickly for maximum effect.

If you like, I can provide a printable PDF version, or create a vegan/dairy‑free version, or step‑by‑step photo guide. Would you like me to do that?