top pulling this up —it’s not a weed. Here’s why. Full article 👇 💬

 

Why we think something is a “weed”

The term “weed” is often thrown around for any plant that’s growing where we don’t want it. But botanically speaking, a weed is just a plant that’s in an unwanted place. Many plants labelled “weeds” are actually edible, ornamental, beneficial for wildlife, or simply harmless. One resource explains:

“So before you reach for the weed‑killer, take a second look — your next meal might be growing in your back yard.” Just Plain Cooking+2Utopia+2

Even more important: some plants look like weeds—especially if growing in cracks, lawns, borders—but they’re actually either native wildflowers, edible greens, or simply something valuable.

At the same time there are lots of plants that should be removed (invasive species, toxic look‑alikes, plants sprayed with herbicides). So this guide is about how to tell the difference, and make an informed decision before pulling.

---

2. How to decide: Weed vs Valued Plant

Here are steps to help you decide whether a plant is a weed or one worth keeping.

2.1 Examine Context & Growth Habit

• Where is it growing? A plant in the middle of your lawn that’s standing tall may look “weedy,” but if it’s showing signs of strong form (flowering, interesting leaves) it might be something you want.

• Is it crowded, choking other plants, or truly invasive? If yes, it may legitimately be a weed in your garden design. If it’s holding its own or even beneficial, consider keeping.

• Has it been sprayed? Plants near roadsides, sprayed lawns, sidewalks can pick up contaminants—so even edible wild plants may be risky. One caution says: “Avoid roadsides, sprayed lawns, and industrial sites.” GardenBeast+1

2.2 Identify the Plant

• Look at leaves, stems, flowers or buds. Are they distinctive? Edible or beneficial plants often have recognizable features.

• Check if there are any toxic look‑alikes. The wild plant world has plenty of “looks like this, but one is safe, one is deadly” pairs. For example: the edible wild carrot vs the poisonous hemlock. homesteadingsuburbia.com+1

• Use trustworthy resources or local experts. Foraging or keeping wild plants involves risk if you mis‑identify.

2.3 Check Purpose or Value

• Is the plant edible? Nutritious? Medicinal? Pollinator friendly? Some “weeds” are great for bees, birds, or soil.

• Is it ornamental or something you like visually? Some wild plants add texture or interest and are worth keeping.

• Is it invasive or causing more harm than benefit? If it spreads aggressively and damages other plants, you may opt to remove it, but with a plan.

2.4 Make an Informed Decision

If you determine:

• Yes, it’s benign or beneficial → Keep it, perhaps manage its growth.

• No, it’s harmful/invasive → Remove it, but perhaps compost or dispose responsibly (not just herbicide).

• Unsure → Leave it for a bit, observe how it grows, and maybe consult a local plant expert.

---

3. Examples of plants that are often pulled as “weeds” but aren’t

Here are several common plants that people mistakenly call weeds, but really they’re edible, native, or just misunderstood.

3.1 Edible Harmony: Purslane

• Purslane (Portulaca oleracea) is often dismissed as a weed because it grows flat, spreads quickly, and thrives in cracks and compacted soil.

• But it’s edible, nutritious (high in omega‑3 fatty acids, vitamins) and has a mild lemony flavour when young. Utopia+1

• If you see it, don’t rush to pull it—unless you don’t want groundcover; you might have a free salad ingredient!

3.2 Chickweed

• Chickweed (Stellaria media) grows low, in mats, often in borders or as what looks like a “weed.”

• But it’s edible in young shoots, has mild flavour, and can be added to salads, soups or pestos. Woodland Trust+1

• Next time you pull it, pause—maybe you can harvest a handful!

3.3 Lamb’s‑quarters (Wild spinach)

• Lamb’s‑quarters (Chenopodium album) is sometimes considered a weed because it grows wild, especially in disturbed soil.

• Yet it’s nutritious—young leaves can substitute for spinach, and it’s part of the “eat the weeds” movement. fairfaxgardening.org+1

• So before pulling, check whether you might want to keep some for cooking.

3.4 Plants that Look Like Something Else (but not “weed” in the negative sense)

Some plants look like weed or like other plants, and misunderstanding leads to pulling. For instance:

• Okra leaves can look like cannabis leaves. GearTrench+1

• Some ornamental hibiscus with palmate leaves resemble hemp/cannabis leaves but are totally fine. myplantin.com

In these cases the plant isn’t necessarily a weed; the problem is mis‑identification or misunderstanding.

---

4. Why it matters — Benefits of Keeping “Weeds”

4.1 Nutritional value

Many wild plants considered “weeds” are actually edible and highly nutritious. For example, edible weeds like chickweed and lamb’s‑quarters offer vitamins, minerals, and flavour. Just Plain Cooking

4.2 Ecological / biodiversity value

Allowing certain plants to remain fosters biodiversity: they can provide pollinator habitat, soil cover, and resilience in your ecosystem. Some “weed” plants may help soil health.

4.3 Aesthetic / low maintenance

Some plants that look “weedy” actually provide ground cover and low maintenance greenery. Pulling them all may make your garden less interesting.

4.4 Foraging & culinary adventure

Rather than always purchasing greens at the store, you might discover free edible plants in your yard (provided they’re safe and untreated). This can connect you more deeply to your space, and reduces waste.

---

5. When you should pull a plant

Of course, not every plant deserves to stay. Here are times when pulling is the right move:

• The plant is a proven invasive species, choking out native plants or spreading aggressively.

• The plant is toxic, dangerous to pets/children, or has poisonous look‑alikes you cannot identify confidently.

• The plant is in a spot where it damages infrastructure (e.g., roots under pavement) or is causing harm.

• The plant is treated with herbicide or pesticide — if it’s been sprayed or near sprayed zones, you may want to remove it rather than eat it. GardenBeast

In each of these cases pull with caution, perhaps wearing gloves, and dispose responsibly.

---

6. How to tell for certain: Quick ID checklist

Below is a handy checklist for you to go through when you spot a potential “weed” and are unsure whether to pull or keep.

Question	If YES → stay or investigate further	If NO → likely weed or at least not desirable
Are the leaves, stems and structure distinctive (not just generic “weed” look)?	Possibly something valuable	Could be generic weed
Does the plant appear healthy, robust, classically edible or ornamental (not weak, scraggly)?	Keep/investigate	Might be weed
Are there edible or beneficial parts (leaves, shoots) you recognise or that match a known edible plant?	Consider harvesting/tending	Less likely edible
Is there safe confirmation of the plant’s ID (book, local expert, reliable website)?	Good to keep	If uncertain → pull or leave until confirmed
Is the area free from spraying, contamination, heavy vehicle traffic, chemicals?	Safer to eat/keep	If not → pulling or at least not eating is safer

If you’re unsure, it’s perfectly fine to wait and observe the plant for a while before pulling. Let it grow, flower, see its habit — many plants become clearer as they mature.

---

7. What to do if it is a good plant — not a weed

If you decide the plant is worthwhile, here are some actions you can take.

7.1 Manage its growth

• Trim or shape it so it doesn’t overtakes the garden.

• Keep it healthy—mulch around it, thin if needed, provide good soil if beneficial.

• If edible, designate a “wild edible” section of your garden or yard so you recognise and manage it intentionally.

7.2 Harvest or Use it (if edible)

If it is an edible wild plant, you might harvest young leaves, shoots, flowers, etc. Some ideas:

• Use young tender leaves in salads (chickweed, lamb’s‑quarters)

• Cook leaves like spinach (wild greens)

• Add into soups, stews, stir‑fries

• Use for teas or garnishes where appropriate

7.3 Incorporate into your gardening plan

• Consider integrating it into a permaculture or low‑maintenance design: groundcover plants that you like can replace “weed‑prone” lawns.

• Use it as a seasonal green or wild food in your diet.

• Appreciate the biodiversity value: it might attract beneficial insects or serve ecological purpose.

---

8. Case Study: “Stop pulling this up — it’s not a weed”

Imagine this scenario: You have a patch of low‑growing, succulent‑stemmed, slightly reddish stem, leaves clustered with a mild lemony flavour. At first glance you think “ugh, another weed.” But then you identify it as purslane. It turns out to be edible, healthy, and beneficial groundcover. Rather than pulling, you can harvest leaves (if you want), allow it to remain, and appreciate that it’s adding value.

Another scenario: You find a smattering of chickweed in your border. Instead of yanking them all, you recognise the tiny white flowers and oval opposite leaves, realise it’s edible, and decide to leave some for harvest or for wildlife.

These examples illustrate the mindset: pause, observe, identify, then decide.

---

9. Cautions & Safety Considerations

• Never eat a wild plant unless you’re 100% sure of its identification. Many toxic plants mimic edible ones. For instance: wild carrot vs poison hemlock. homesteadingsuburbia.com+1

• Avoid plants from sprayed areas or near heavy traffic roads, as they may carry chemical residues or pollutants. GardenBeast

• Harvest responsibly. Don’t over‑harvest wild plants in a way that harms local populations.

• Be mindful of allergies. Even edible plants can cause reactions in some people.

• If unsure, leave it or remove and compost (if safe).

• For foraging and wild plants: consult local botany/foraging groups, field guides, credible websites.

---

10. Summary: The Decision Process

In summary:

1. Don’t reflexively pull every “weed‑looking” plant.

2. Pause and examine: growth habit, leaves, stems, environment.

3. Identify with reputable resources.

4. Decide: Keep, or remove. If keep → manage; if remove → do so responsibly.

5. If edible → harvest thoughtfully and integrate into your garden or diet.

This simple process helps you avoid accidentally getting rid of plants that are beneficial, edible, or simply nice to have. It also reduces waste and enhances your connection to your outdoor space.

---

Final Thought

So the next time you reach for the weeds in your garden, pause. Ask: Is this really a weed, or is it a plant with value that I’ve mistaken for one?

Because often the answer is: “Stop pulling this up—it’s not a weed.” And if you let it be, you might gain more than you expected: a free edible green, more biodiversity, or just a more interesting garden.

If you’d like, I can help you identify the specific plant you’re looking at (you can send a description or photo) and we can decide whether it’s safe to keep or pull. Would you like me to help with that?